By
Larry Babcock
This
paper originally appeared in The Antique Radio
Gazette, Volume 16, Number 4. Permission to
present it here has been granted by the
Antique Wireless Association, and they retain
all rights to its distribution and
reproduction. Only not-for-profit personnal
use is authorized for any hardcopy printouts
of this page. I want to thank Mr. Larry
Babcock for the permission to use his article
based on a talk given by the late Ken Conrad.
I want also to thank Mr. Bill Fizette, AWA
President and AWA OTB Editor Marc Ellis for
their support of The James Millen Society.
This article is comprehensive with respect to
the early National receivers. However, it
should be noted that since this was based on a
talk given by Ken Conrad and that most of the
receivers discussed were those being
demonstrated at the time. Therefore, such
popular receivers like the FB-7 and the early
NC series are not mentioned. With this in mind
the reader will still find valuable
information contained in this paper that is
not found elsewhere.
The
following article was reconstructed by Larry
Babcock from a talk given to the Niagara
Frontier Wireless Association, (N.F.W.A.) by
Ken Conrad in 1983. Kenny was a ardent
collector and historian of the National
Company prior to his death in the summer of
1988. The National information presented is
all from Kenny. The information was
preserved by Larry Babcock for this report.
Back in the 1930's the outstanding
commerical radio equipment was made by the
National Company in Malden, Mass. They had an
assortment of sets. Most were for short wave
work. They made the SW3, the SW4 and the SW5.
The number in the model number was the number
of tubes in the set. They were 3 to 5 tubes
and all were regenerative. They all had one or
two stages of R.F. amplification. The SW3 and
SW4 had a single R.F. Stage.
In the early 1930's National also made the AGS
which is highly sought by collectors these
days. There were only a few ever made. Less
accessories, and that means less coils, less
power supply, less tubes, less speaker, less
everything except the box listed for $180.00.
In those days that was a lot of money, more
than 1/3 the cost of an automobile, so you see
why very few were ever made and very few
amateurs could ever buy one. Remember in 1932
and 1933 there weren't very many dollars
around. Only a few affluent hams could buy am
AGS.
Back in 1933 the state-of-the-art of short
wave reception was very poor compared to
nowadays. Most hams had home made two tube
regenerative sets with a detector and one
stage of audio. A few owned the National SW3
which also had an R.F. stage (plus
regenerative detector and an audio stage). The
most advanced amateur who has some cash (a few
of them did but not me) spent up to $100.00
for a Hammarlund Comet Pro. A lot of people
remember this set but it was not very good.
It didn't have an R.F. stage. It had poor
selectivity and a superhet was not suited for
short wave reception in those days. A good
regenerative set like the SW3 could run rings
around a superhet with no problem at all!
There was a real need for a good superhet like
the AGS to be built.
In an article from CQ magazine written by
James Millen of National it was stated that
"It was in this chilly atmosphere that James
Millen who was W1HRX and other engineers of
the National Company commenced to design an
advanced short wave superhet". The initial
requirement came from the federal government.
The Bureau of Air Commerce which was the
predecessor of the present Civil Aeronautics
Authority was in the process of replacing the
revolving light beacons used for air
navigation with a comprehensive ground to air
radio network. The communications system was
divided into three groups. First, the ground
transmitting equipment was to be developed and
manufatured by G.E. The airborne radio
equipment developed and manufactured by
Aircraft Radio Corporation who later developed
the SCR 274N. The ground station receivers
were designed and manufatured by National. The
BAC and National signed a contract to produce
several hundred AGS recievers to replace the
antiquated sets in use at the time.
Incidentally, AGS stands for Aviation Ground
Station.
W1HRX started to work on the AGS design and
became the leader of development. He didn't
have much to go on. His previous experience
was the old Browning Drake set of several
years previous along with the SW3 and SW5 of
National. The problems to get a good short
wave set in those days were tremendous.
The first AGS receivers were made on a
government contract with a few commercial sets
also sold to affluent amateurs. The difference
between the contracted ones and those sold on
the open market was just in the name plate.
There were only between 200 and 400 sets sold
to hams. That was very few even in those days
and is why there aren't very many around
today. The AGS was very shortly made obsolete
by the HRO.
(Actually the FB-7 superhet came shortly after
the AGS, which was much more affordable and
sold in comparatively good quantities. - JMS).
The AGS used a new
crystal filter just being developed. It was a
single conversion superhet. It had one R.F.
and two I.F. stages, an AVC, VFO and audio
stages. The crystal filter was available if
ordered special. With it the receiver was
named the AGSX. Ken Conrad's AGS shown when it
first gave this talk to the NFWA was the
original type without the crystal filter.
The intermediate frequency was 500 KHz. There
is no automatic volume control in this set.
None at all. The volume was adjusted only by
the bias control potentiometer for the R.F.
and I.F. stages. AVC was applied to the first
detector, a scheme frowned on today as the
ever changing control voltage tends to pull
the high frequency oscillator and causes
strong signals to flutter but they got around
this. In the AGS they injected the local
oscillator signal into the plate circuit of
the R.F. amplifier and inductively coupled the
mixing signal into the first signal. That was
how it was done.
Some aspects of the design were amazing. How
to control the inductance and capacitance and
make the tuned stages all track, that was a
real job and to keep it right on the button!
They figured that plug in coils were the way
to go rather than having the coils permanently
wired in. The AGS has five sets of three coils
each and on the panel there is a chart which
shows the frequency band covered by each set
of coils.
This helped the operator pick out the ground
station that he wanted to monitor. The tuning
capacitors were hand measured. The tuning
range and oscillator tracking were corrected
by moving a tap on the wire connecting the
tuning capacitor to the plug in coil. That was
the final adjustment.
Using hand labor for calibration of course is
impossible today because of the price of labor
but in those days an engineer got a salary of
$20- to $40- per week! Imagine that.
Technicians earned from 20 to 35 cents an
hour. This is why each AGS could be hand
calibrated and the chart was right.
The chassis was made of heavy drawn 1/8" think
aluminum. The panel is very heavy steel firmly
bolted to the chassis. This made a very rigid
and absolutely tight assembly. The tuned
frequency wouldn't change even if you dropped
the set on the floor. The high frequency
oscillator is in the middle of the unit and
driven by a disk dial.
This receiver has a very unusual dial. It is
the same as was later used on the HRO. The
dial has five openings and is calibrated from
zero to 500. Each time that the dial is turned
passed one of the little openings, the scale
is automatically changed. The number viewed
through the hole jumps another fifty points!
Each one of the line segment divisions that
just cover a band. You can read to one tenth
of a division directly and each division is
equivalent to about 1 KHz so you can get down
to 100 cycles direct reading. A heck of a lot
of the receivers today don't even get near
this. Imagine, this was over 50 years ago! The
AGS was designed to work forever. You turn one
on today and it will work immediately. Even if
it has not been operated for fifty years that
set will work!
The SW4 and SW5 both had plug in coils. Both
were shown when Ken gave this talk to the
NFWA. Incidentally, before his death, Kenny
donated his entire (large) collection of
National receivers to the AWA and they are
currently on display in the AWA museum. The
SW3 was introduced by National in 1931. It was
a low priced set. Because of its very light
weight, it was adapted for use by the
airlines.
At that time other aircraft receivers were
heavy things and didn't perform to well. They
had poor selectivity and were bothered by the
planes ignition system.
Pan American was about to start flights to
South America and needed a very light weight
receiver. The only sets available at that time
were the National SW4 and SW5. They were too
big, too heavy and another problem was that
coils would absorb moisture when flying over
the ocean. This made the tuned frequency
wander all over the place.
In about 1930 the old Boonton Rubber Company
started making Bakelite coil form moldings for
their sister company the Boonton Radio
Company. The molding powder sold by the
original Bakelite Corp. was based on the use
of wood filler which was very hydroscopic.
Molding in those days was done with steam, not
electric heat and as a consequence the molding
rooms were extremely humid. The coils forms
molded by this process varied tremendously in
Q. Good and bad coils looked just alike. You
couldn't tell a good coils by looking at it.
To solve this problem the Boonton Rubber Co.
changed from the old filler to ground mica and
electrically heated presses. For the first
time this method made uniform inductors. The
new material was called R39 and was registered
with this trademark. This new material was
used in making the SW3 starting in the summer
of 1931. During the long and useful life of
the SW3 over 10,000 sets were made and used by
everybody including Pan Am. It is still a good
receiver today. The SW3 had tremendous range.
You could get coils all the way from 9 to 2000
meters! The SW series sets are collectors
items today and they are good ones. They are
so stable that you can read sideband on them
with no problem!
National used separate power supplies for many
years because of the heating problem. With the
power supply separate the heat from the
transformer and rectifier didn't raise the
temperature of the receiver and change the
tuned frequency. With everything in the same
box the temperature would not stabilize for
along time and the frequency would drift until
then. The power supply provided about 200
volts to the plates.
Manufacture of the SW3 continued for many
years. The original had tubes with 2.5 volt
filaments. Later they were made with 6 volt
tubes and even with metal tubes before
production finally folded.
The little National 110 (1-10) was
also shown when Kenny gave his talk to the
NFWA at the Buffalo, NY meeting. The #110 is a
four tube super regenerative set. The tuned
R.F. amplifier uses a very tiny type 954 tube.
The detector was a type 955 in a
self-quenching super regenerative circuit. It
was transformer coupled to the first audi
stage, a 6J5. The 6J5 was then resistance
coupled to the 6V6 output stage. This was
unusual. Kenny said that he didn't know the
reason why national designed it this way
rather than using transformer coupling for the
added gain, but that was the way it was.
The model 110 had six separate pairs of small
clear plastic coils. They are extremely small
and so shaped that they can be picked up and
plugged in very easily. If you picked them up
by the coil itself it would probably collapse
because they are so small and delicate. This
set will get down to 300MHz. It tunes the one
to ten meter band and it will get down to one
meter. This was a long time ago too, way back
in the fortys. (I liked the way Kenny said
"down to 300 MHz" rather than up to 300 MHz.
Here's a man who still thought in terms of
wave length rather than frequency like us
young guys!).
The model 110 had a separate A.C. power supply
or could be operated with batteries. The
manual didn't give the price but did have
charts giving the frequency coverage for each
set of plug in coils. It also had the same
unusual tuning dial that was first used on the
AGS.
The HRO is my favorite receiver. Some of the
commercial airlines used the National AGS, but
others wanted a little better receiver. They
wanted one for CW that could also work with
the new Western Electric phone transmitters
(voice) that were about to be installed in
aircraft.
Now consider the state of the art in 1933 and
1934. The great majority of hams had home made
regenerative sets or SW3's. A superhet was
useless, they thought, for CW and pretty poor
on general shortwave. It was considered a
great thing to get anything on a short wave
superhet so National started to develop the
HRO. It was a coordinated effort. This
receiver as developed on the east coast and
the west coast of the U.S. at the same time!
There was 3000 miles separating the mechanical
and electrical teams! Wasn't that crazy? Wow.
The west coast HRO team was coordinated by
Herbert Hoover Jr.. James Millen was in charge
of the east coast. They were in a hurry.
The tool makers required a job number for
their overtime slips. Since none had been
assigned, they took it upon themselves to use
the initials "H" "O" "R", or "HOR" abbreviated
from "Hell of a Rush!" since that was the
state of affairs. Now known as the HOR the new
prototype was carried by Millen to Pasadena
for circuit revision. Bugs were worked out. It
was a success. By this time however, some of
the participants had doubts about the name. So
they therefore renamed it the HRO. This change
was made just in time to catch the first ad in
December 1934 QST.
But I have digressed from my story. Getting
back to the design, Herb Hoover, Jr. set up an
experimental laboratory in his garage under
the direction of Howard Morgan of Western
Electric. Howard and his technicians went to
work developing a circuit based on experience
gained with the AGS and what the airlines were
looking for. First the specifications were
established. It had to have superior image
rejection which called for two stages of R.F.,
not just one. The selectivity would require a
crystal filter be included. Jim Millen had
designed what they called a epicyclic dial so
you could read to one part in five hundred. In
other words the band spread on that dial was
over 12 feet on a ham band!
The specifications for the HRO also required
very good AVC and an S meter. The designers
believed that plug in coils were the answer.
They didn't want band switching and instead
planned to have a new four bank plug in coil
catacomb. Each coil deck had its own
calibration chart. To reduce hum and heating
effects the power supply was separate. As a
whole, the receiver was years ahead of its
time. It is one of the first examples of
system designed equipment otherwise unknown
before World War II.
The HRO was very outstanding, a classic. It
had two R.F. stages, a crystal filter, two
I.F. stages, AVC, BFO and 450 degrees band
spread on any amateur band!
There was a system built into the catacombs.
Each coil had two little screw holes with
little machine screws in them. If you put the
screw in to the hole on the left you get
general coverage. When you remove the other
one you get just the ham band over the whole
dial. It was simple. The screws just shorted a
condenser or opened one across part of the
coil. But it worked and it gave trememdous
band spread!
At first there was a lot of drift but in
working on the problem they found out that
most of the drift was in the oscillator tube
and they were able to eliminate the problem.
The HRO was so beautifully made that it would
be impossible to build today. It would cost
hundreds of dollars just to make the coil
forms, the tuning condensers and the
insulators. There was so much hand work in
both the mechanical and electrical
calibration.
One of the early owners of the HRO was Charlie
Kolster. He was so impressed with the set that
he suggested that Jim Millen replace his old
two district call sign with a first district
and have 1HRO in honor of the set. But the FCC
goofed and he ended up with 1HRX (I believe that the
"W" letter prefix was already in existance at
this time so these calls should be preceded
with that letter - JMS.)
That was how the FCC did things. In spite of
the call sign mix up, the set was an instant
success.
Braniff Airlines bought a lot of HRO
receivers. The set was so far ahead of time
that they found it could be operated
unattended. They installed a lot of HRO
receivers on telephone poles spaced 50 miles
apart. That way they could get the coverage to
communicate with airplanes all along the
route. At that time there was no radar, or
beacons or anything. So they mounted HRO's in
boxes on poles every 50 miles along the main
route of the aircraft. These receivers ran
continuously 24 hours a day! They were tuned
to thirty one hundred and five kilocycles
(KHz) which was the aircraft frequency.
The receiever outputs were patched into land
lines and could be monitored in Kansas City,
Dallas, Tulsa, Oklahoma City or anywhere. They
had continuous voice monitor of the planes all
along the route. That's where the HRO got the
big impetus. Also, the Howard Hughes flight
around the world used the HRO. He had two at
each ground station. That is what he thought
of the HRO!
The HRO was so designed that with the crystal
filter, now this is almost unbelievable, you
could get down to 20 cycles! (Hz) That's the
selectivity of the HRO., twenty cycles! (Not
kilocycles) That is better than practically
any set made today, and this was over fifty
years ago.
The HRO remained popular until after World War
II. By then SSB was coming in and the HRO was
finally on the downgrade. That is the story of
the HRO. It was a wonderful set. I don't care
what they make today, what the price is or
anything, they don't make them to have the
design, the selectivity and the durability!
After fifty years I can turn one on and she'll
still go. They are worth the time and effort
to restore.
Question:
Ken did anyone ever make a rack mounted HRO
like your AGS?
Answer:
Yes, And they were provided with a door to
slide the coils in and out of the set.
|