By Alan Douglas
This paper originally
appeared in the AWA Old Timers Bulletin, June
1981. Permission to present it here has been
granted by the Antique Wireless Association,
and they retain all rights to its distribution
and reproduction. Only not-for-profit
personnal use is authorized for any hardcopy
printouts of this page. I want to thank Mr.
William Fizette, AWA President and Mr. Marc
Ellis, OTB Editor for their support and
assistance.
The story of Jim
Millen, his work with National and later his
own company, has been covered before (CQ, July
1967, pp.26-31) but it would take a dozen such
articles to do justice to the subject.
In 13 years he transformed the old National
Toy Company into the country's foremost ham
and commercial radio manufacturer, but when
National's backers tried to freeze Jim out of
the profits (by paying themselves high
salaries to reduce profits to be split) he
knew it was time to form his own company. To
guard against similar problems in the future,
he became a banker himself, and indeed is
still active in that profession.
It was a good time to be in electronics; the
industry was small enough so that many
engineers and executives knew each other
personally. As an illustration of how the
industry was run, among those who played the
game like sportsmen, Jim tells of a request
from RCA for his company to build their
service oscilloscopes.
He needed a $100,000 loan to set up production
lines, which was out of the question through
formal channels. But RCA arranged to sell
CRT's to Millen who would install them in the
scopes and sell them back to RCA at the same
price. Millen's invoice to RCA was paid within
ten days, but RCA allowed six months to pay
their invoices. Result: a $100,000 interest
free loan!
Similar arrangements could be made for an RCA
license, which 'formally' cost $100,000, far
too much for a small company to pay. But
Millen could license RCA to use some of his
lesser patents for $90,000, and pay them their
$100,000, in effect getting the license for
$10,000.
In May 1938, QST carried a notice of the new
James Millen Company, and in October their
first ad and catalog appeared. Succeeding
catalogs featured a rapidly-expanding line of
mechanical components, all soundly engineered
- some have survived unchanged for forty years
- but this was just the tip of the iceberg.
What really paid the company bills was the
subcontracting work for firms such as RCA and
GE. They found it far cheaper to have Millen
make equipment than to set up their own
production lines. It might be service scopes
for RCA, two-way police radios for GE, wartime
gear for MIT's Radiation Lab, or marine radar
for Raytheon.
Sometimes the products were fully engineered
and ready for production; more often Millen
would receive an electrical prototype and
would do all the mechanical design themselves.
As new components were designed and tooled up,
they would appear in the catalog. Subcontract
work accounted for perhaps three-quarters of
Millen's total output, and kept the amateur
activities afloat.
Millen's approach to ham equipment was to take
electrical designs originated by others, and
to adapt them mechanically for commercial
production. Their first venture was a tunable
heterodyne filter, used in the headphone line
outboard of a receiver, adapted from a
September 1939 QST article and made under
license (given gratis) by its author Dr. Ray
Woodward. In January 1941 QST published a
description of Henry Rice's clever VFO called
the "Variarm", and shortly Millen had a
commercial model going.
Jim Millen had intended from the beginning, to
make an amateur receiver, but not until the
war's end was he in the position to do so. He
had an elaborate design ready, a receiver
incorporating every feature a ham could want:
direct frequency readout, ten ham- and
general-coverage bands, motor-assisted tuning,
motor-driven bandswitching, etc etc.
It appeared in the early 1947 catalog, as a
"custom-built" model, but it must have been
apparent, some time before, that it was not a
profitable venture: no ham could afford it.
Only one prototype was ever finished.
A "cheaper" model was under design at the same
time, using a more traditional approach, with
sliding coil catacomb (like the
Millen-designed pre-war National models) and
band-set-bandspread tuning condensors. This
model DFP-201 is absolutely typical of
Millen's design philosophy, that a sound
mechanical design was the foundation on which
the electrical design would be built.
Millen unveiled the DFP201 (and the 501) at a
Chicago trade show in May 1947, and put it in
his catalog, but it was soon obvious that even
this "cheaper" model could never be sold;
their no-compromise design philosophy made it
far to expensive. The few prototypes that were
completed were said to have cost $2100 apiece
to build. Both models were immediately
withdrawn, and revised catalogs printed.
Through the 1950's and 60's new ham equipment
appeared in Millen catalogs, side by side with
mechanical components.
After 38 years it was time to pull the plug.
Their antiquated factory building was in the
path of urban renewal, and massive renovations
would have been needed to meet new OSHA safety
regulations. Jim suffered a heart attack and
had to reduce his activities, so in May 1977
the factory was closed. Jim retired to his
farm and his banking interests. He feels lucky
to have been in the electronics business when
there was room for individual effort, and
certainly the rest of us are lucky to have
benefitted from his contributions.
My thanks to (naturally) Jim Millen, his
production superintendent Gene Williams and
30-year employee Mel Dunbrack, and to Tom
Rutherford who salvaged from the factory much
of the equipment that otherwise would have
been scrapped.
|